From

Location

Message

Date Posted

Hyde Park, Utah USA

Okay, I wanted to get everyone’s opinion on whether it would be better to directly seed into soil or planting containerized seedling given conducive soil and weather conditions? In my mind direct seeding would give the plant a deeper root and avoid any transplant shock. Planted in the right container, it might enhance lateral rooting. What are your thoughts? Any experience with direct seeding? Thanks!

1/1/2020 9:27:56 PM

Menomonie, WI (mail@gr8pumpkin.net)

Two many unknowns for direct seeding. Soil temp, cut worms, seed maggots. Cost of the seeds are a factor

1/2/2020 7:35:20 AM

Upa Creek, Mo

If I had multiple of the seed, I would maybe try both methods, and then put the transplant in the ground next to the direct seeded one to let them compete. I do direct seed with field pumpkins and all other varieties each year and never really noticed a difference. They tend to grow faster inside vs. in the April outside soil which would offset the transplant shock\delay. The deeper roots are a good point with direct seeding. No matter how big the inside container, the roots will always be a bit bound and wrapped up against the walls. Following this post.

1/2/2020 9:28:28 AM

Billerica,Massachusetts

more control over indoor starting, direct you're at the mercy of the weather

1/2/2020 4:14:46 PM

Menomonie, WI (mail@gr8pumpkin.net)

Plus direct seeding you can not control the direction of the main vine being opposite of the first true leaf.

1/3/2020 7:38:42 AM

Upa Creek, Mo

Yes, the direction of the vine, great point Engel. Forgot about that one, and that is a huge factor since who wants to 180 a new plant?

1/3/2020 7:57:16 AM